Quebec told Longueuil police to disregard court order on racial profiling, says anti-racism group
Rob Lurie, CTV News Montreal Videojournalist
An anti-racism group says it has copies of email exchanges to support its claims that Quebec told the City of Longueuil to disregard a court order on racial profiling.
Joel DeBellefeuille, executive director of the Red Coalition, said he’s been pulled over by police a dozen times in the past 15 years.
In 2012, Longueuil police followed him and his family as they were dropping off his son at daycare. As a result of that incident, he was awarded $12,000 in damages.
But it’s what he found while following up on that case that shocked him
"I was really floored," he said in an interview Tuesday.
As a result of his case, a human rights tribunal ruled Longueuil police had to start collecting and publishing race-based data for police stops by 2021. DeBellefeuille has long claimed the city was defying the ruling.
And now he obtained exchanges between the Longueuil police chief and the human rights commission. In one dated Sept. 29, 2021, then-police chief Fady Dagher, writes the ministry informed him it was working on guidelines for all police forces to collect race-based data.
Dagher writes, "the public security ministry asked Longueuil police to wait for this solution to be put in place," adding he believed it should be ready by the end of 2021.
Dagher is set to become Montreal's next police chief.
In a follow-up exchange a few months later, Dagher writes the policy will be deployed "in the first quarter of 2022." DeBellefeuille says he's still waiting to see that policy.
"How many cases do you think from the last two-and-a-half, three years could have potentially been avoided? It could have potentially deterred some officers from intercepting people based [on] their appearance and racially profiling them?" he said.
On Nov. 18, 2022, lawyer Julius Grey sent, on behalf of DeBellefeuille, a letter to the City of Longueuil warning that it was "in breach" of the court judgment, Noovo Info reported.
"We hereby put you on notice to comply with all provisions of said judgment within 5 days upon receipt of this notice," the letter reads.
"Should you fail to comply, we will take out legal proceedings against you without any further warning nor delay, and we will pursue the highest legal penalty possible in this matter."
DeBellefeuille told CTV that the city will be in Superior Court in Longueuil Thursday to respond to an allegation of contempt of court over the delay in obeying the court order.
Dagher declined to comment on the email exchanges when reached by CTV News.
A spokesperson for the Longueuil police said in an email that the public security ministry never asked them to defy the court order or break the law.
Louise Quintin, a Public Safety Ministry (MSP) spokesperson, told CTV it would never make such a request.
"The MSP has been working for more than a year to implement a framework and mechanism for data collection on police stops ... a first capsule of the new plan will be delivered in the spring of 2023," she wrote in a statement.
DeBellefeuille still wonders why it's taking so long he said if police are serious about ending racial profiling, they should start following the human rights tribunal's ruling immediately.
An anti-racism group says it has copies of email exchanges to support its claims that Quebec told the City of Longueuil to disregard a court order on racial profiling.
Joel DeBellefeuille, executive director of the Red Coalition, said he’s been pulled over by police a dozen times in the past 15 years.
In 2012, Longueuil police followed him and his family as they were dropping off his son at daycare. As a result of that incident, he was awarded $12,000 in damages.
But it’s what he found while following up on that case that shocked him
"I was really floored," he said in an interview Tuesday.
As a result of his case, a human rights tribunal ruled Longueuil police had to start collecting and publishing race-based data for police stops by 2021. DeBellefeuille has long claimed the city was defying the ruling.
And now he obtained exchanges between the Longueuil police chief and the human rights commission. In one dated Sept. 29, 2021, then-police chief Fady Dagher, writes the ministry informed him it was working on guidelines for all police forces to collect race-based data.
Dagher writes, "the public security ministry asked Longueuil police to wait for this solution to be put in place," adding he believed it should be ready by the end of 2021.
Dagher is set to become Montreal's next police chief.
In a follow-up exchange a few months later, Dagher writes the policy will be deployed "in the first quarter of 2022." DeBellefeuille says he's still waiting to see that policy.
"How many cases do you think from the last two-and-a-half, three years could have potentially been avoided? It could have potentially deterred some officers from intercepting people based [on] their appearance and racially profiling them?" he said.
On Nov. 18, 2022, lawyer Julius Grey sent, on behalf of DeBellefeuille, a letter to the City of Longueuil warning that it was "in breach" of the court judgment, Noovo Info reported.
"We hereby put you on notice to comply with all provisions of said judgment within 5 days upon receipt of this notice," the letter reads.
"Should you fail to comply, we will take out legal proceedings against you without any further warning nor delay, and we will pursue the highest legal penalty possible in this matter."
DeBellefeuille told CTV that the city will be in Superior Court in Longueuil Thursday to respond to an allegation of contempt of court over the delay in obeying the court order.
Dagher declined to comment on the email exchanges when reached by CTV News.
A spokesperson for the Longueuil police said in an email that the public security ministry never asked them to defy the court order or break the law.
Louise Quintin, a Public Safety Ministry (MSP) spokesperson, told CTV it would never make such a request.
"The MSP has been working for more than a year to implement a framework and mechanism for data collection on police stops ... a first capsule of the new plan will be delivered in the spring of 2023," she wrote in a statement.
DeBellefeuille still wonders why it's taking so long he said if police are serious about ending racial profiling, they should start following the human rights tribunal's ruling immediately.
Recent
The Red Coalition Inc. Files $1 Million Human Rights Complaint Against the Québec Government Over Discriminatory Impact of Bill 96
August 21st, 2024
Why has this N.D.G. social housing building been sitting vacant for 11 years?
August 6th, 2024
"Beyond the shadows" tackles Quebec racism
July 11th, 2024
Quebec parents demand $1.4-million from teacher, school board for stolen intellectual property
February 16th, 2024
Canadian art teacher accused of using ‘sweatshop of children’ after selling students’ work online
February 15th, 2024
Archive
2024
February
2023
January
March
2022
February
April
Quebec study exposes dramatic increase in police fundingNew initiative asks Montreal, Ottawa residents to film police interventionsA New Initiative is Asking MontrealMontrealers to have a say in hiring next police chief'We need to humanize the police': Que. police association aims to improve public image with new campaignSPVM investigation follows video appearing to show abuse by two Montreal police officersVideo shows Montreal police officer pushing homeless man into concrete block; SPVM investigating
May
June
2021
May
June
July
Advocacy groups and the Red Coalition petition the Minister of Public Safety Canada, requesting the enactment of a legislation to prohibit racial profiling by law enforcementThe Red Coalition Endorses STOPMTL.ca Offering Full Support For Its New Interactive Self-Reporting Map, For Police Stops in Montreal
August
The Red Coalition Condemns the Killing of 37-year-old Jean-René “Junior” Olivier a Black Resident of Repentigny, QuebecMunicipal election candidates announced for C.D.N.-N.D.G., Île-Bizard, Sud-OuestMarianna Naturals’ CEO, Co-Founder & Human Rights Advocate, Joel DeBellefeuille Vies For, City Councillor Seat in the CDN-NDG Loyola District of MontrealHow the killing of a Black man in Repentigny is fuelling calls to end racism in Quebec policing"Calling them out"
2020
September
November
December
Marianna Naturals Corp. Announces It Has Been Approved as A Walmart Marketplace SellerLandmark tribunal decision in profiling case paves the way for major police reform in QuebecMarianna Naturals Corp. Launches Beta-Version of their Skin Diagnostics Tool that uses Artificial-IntelligenceHindsight 2020: Outrage over systemic racism became undeniableFighting Systemic Racism- Most Fascinating 2020
2016
2013
2012
2011
Categories
no categories