Rights tribunal hands down landmark ruling in Longueuil racial profiling case
The ruling is "precedent-setting and raises the benchmark on the identification of and measurement and training on racial profiling in Quebec," Fo Niemi says.
Eight years after two police officers tailed Joël DeBellefeuille without justification as he drove his son to daycare, the Quebec Human Rights Tribunal has ordered the city of Longueuil and one of the officers to pay him $12,000 in moral and punitive damages, plus interest.
In a decision rendered Nov. 17, Justice Christian Brunel said the evidence overwhelmingly proved DeBellefeuille, who is Black, was the victim of racial profiling.
He also ordered Longueuil to collect and publish race-based data on police checks starting next year, and to train all police officers and management on racial profiling within the next two years.
Brunel also instructed the Quebec Human Rights and Youth Rights Commission to pay legal costs in the case, given the long delays in its handling of it.
The ruling upholds a non-binding decision by the commission in March 2018. It also goes further than that decision, in ordering the city to carry out race-based data collection.
Fo Niemi, executive director of the Centre for Research-Action on Race Relations (CRARR), hailed the decision as a legal landmark that follows eight years of efforts to seek redress in the profiling case.
“It’s precedent-setting and raises the benchmark on the identification of and measurement and training on racial profiling in Quebec,” he said.
The ruling is “the first court decision in which race-based data collection is ordered by the court,” Niemi noted.
“It has wide ramifications for public policy,” he added.
Race-based data collection “is a necessary measure in order to better document the extent of racial profiling,” as well as to raise awareness within the police department and inspire public confidence, Brunel wrote in his decision.
“In a democracy, this trust remains essential to maintaining social peace and living together. Police authorities need to be sensitive to this and engage with determination in resolving the complex issues associated with racial profiling and the prejudices and stereotypes that fuel it,” he added.
In April 2018, Longueuil refused to comply with the commission’s recommendation to pay DeBellefeuille $12,000 in damages. It also rejected the commission’s non-binding order to provide training on racism and discrimination, saying that all of its police officers had already received racial profiling training between 2012 and 2015.
However, Brunel issued detailed and explicit instructions on racial profiling training the city must provide to all police officers and managers. Subjects to be covered must include case law, conscious and unconscious prejudices among police, best practices to counter profiling, and the damaging consequences of profiling on victims, he said. The training must be updated regularly and employees’ knowledge must be tested, the judge decreed.
DeBellefeuille is scheduled to react Monday morning at CRARR’s office.
The case dates back to March 22, 2012, when he drove his then-17-month-old son to daycare, with his wife and 16-year-old niece in the car. Spotting him at the wheel of the BMW, police officers Dominic Polidoro and Jean-Claude Bleu Voua made a U-turn and followed him for 11 blocks. Outside the daycare, the officers demanded his ID and returned to their cruiser to check his licence and registration.
In 2016, the Quebec Police Ethics Committee dropped a complaint against the two officers because Bleu Voua, who had been dismissed from the force for unrelated reasons, had left the country and could not be traced. DeBellefeuille has also complained of other cases of racial profiling by Longueuil police.
Eight years after two police officers tailed Joël DeBellefeuille without justification as he drove his son to daycare, the Quebec Human Rights Tribunal has ordered the city of Longueuil and one of the officers to pay him $12,000 in moral and punitive damages, plus interest.
In a decision rendered Nov. 17, Justice Christian Brunel said the evidence overwhelmingly proved DeBellefeuille, who is Black, was the victim of racial profiling.
He also ordered Longueuil to collect and publish race-based data on police checks starting next year, and to train all police officers and management on racial profiling within the next two years.
Brunel also instructed the Quebec Human Rights and Youth Rights Commission to pay legal costs in the case, given the long delays in its handling of it.
The ruling upholds a non-binding decision by the commission in March 2018. It also goes further than that decision, in ordering the city to carry out race-based data collection.
Fo Niemi, executive director of the Centre for Research-Action on Race Relations (CRARR), hailed the decision as a legal landmark that follows eight years of efforts to seek redress in the profiling case.
“It’s precedent-setting and raises the benchmark on the identification of and measurement and training on racial profiling in Quebec,” he said.
The ruling is “the first court decision in which race-based data collection is ordered by the court,” Niemi noted.
“It has wide ramifications for public policy,” he added.
Race-based data collection “is a necessary measure in order to better document the extent of racial profiling,” as well as to raise awareness within the police department and inspire public confidence, Brunel wrote in his decision.
“In a democracy, this trust remains essential to maintaining social peace and living together. Police authorities need to be sensitive to this and engage with determination in resolving the complex issues associated with racial profiling and the prejudices and stereotypes that fuel it,” he added.
In April 2018, Longueuil refused to comply with the commission’s recommendation to pay DeBellefeuille $12,000 in damages. It also rejected the commission’s non-binding order to provide training on racism and discrimination, saying that all of its police officers had already received racial profiling training between 2012 and 2015.
However, Brunel issued detailed and explicit instructions on racial profiling training the city must provide to all police officers and managers. Subjects to be covered must include case law, conscious and unconscious prejudices among police, best practices to counter profiling, and the damaging consequences of profiling on victims, he said. The training must be updated regularly and employees’ knowledge must be tested, the judge decreed.
DeBellefeuille is scheduled to react Monday morning at CRARR’s office.
The case dates back to March 22, 2012, when he drove his then-17-month-old son to daycare, with his wife and 16-year-old niece in the car. Spotting him at the wheel of the BMW, police officers Dominic Polidoro and Jean-Claude Bleu Voua made a U-turn and followed him for 11 blocks. Outside the daycare, the officers demanded his ID and returned to their cruiser to check his licence and registration.
In 2016, the Quebec Police Ethics Committee dropped a complaint against the two officers because Bleu Voua, who had been dismissed from the force for unrelated reasons, had left the country and could not be traced. DeBellefeuille has also complained of other cases of racial profiling by Longueuil police.
Recent
Quebec parents demand $1.4-million from teacher, school board for stolen intellectual property
February 16th, 2024
Canadian art teacher accused of using ‘sweatshop of children’ after selling students’ work online
February 15th, 2024
The Red Coalition Says Hockey Canada Must Confront Racism In Canadian Hockey
November 3rd, 2023
Outrage au tribunal : l’affaire doit être plutôt entendue en Cour supérieure, dit la Ville
March 28th, 2023
City of Longueuil facing contempt charges related to police racial profiling
March 15th, 2023
Archive
2024
2023
January
March
2022
February
April
Quebec study exposes dramatic increase in police fundingNew initiative asks Montreal, Ottawa residents to film police interventionsA New Initiative is Asking MontrealMontrealers to have a say in hiring next police chief'We need to humanize the police': Que. police association aims to improve public image with new campaignVideo shows Montreal police officer pushing homeless man into concrete block; SPVM investigatingSPVM investigation follows video appearing to show abuse by two Montreal police officers
May
June
2021
May
June
July
Advocacy groups and the Red Coalition petition the Minister of Public Safety Canada, requesting the enactment of a legislation to prohibit racial profiling by law enforcementThe Red Coalition Endorses STOPMTL.ca Offering Full Support For Its New Interactive Self-Reporting Map, For Police Stops in Montreal
August
The Red Coalition Condemns the Killing of 37-year-old Jean-René “Junior” Olivier a Black Resident of Repentigny, QuebecMunicipal election candidates announced for C.D.N.-N.D.G., Île-Bizard, Sud-OuestMarianna Naturals’ CEO, Co-Founder & Human Rights Advocate, Joel DeBellefeuille Vies For, City Councillor Seat in the CDN-NDG Loyola District of MontrealHow the killing of a Black man in Repentigny is fuelling calls to end racism in Quebec policing"Calling them out"
2020
September
November
December
Marianna Naturals Corp. Announces It Has Been Approved as A Walmart Marketplace SellerLandmark tribunal decision in profiling case paves the way for major police reform in QuebecMarianna Naturals Corp. Launches Beta-Version of their Skin Diagnostics Tool that uses Artificial-IntelligenceHindsight 2020: Outrage over systemic racism became undeniableFighting Systemic Racism- Most Fascinating 2020
2016
2013
2012
2011
Categories
no categories